Police begin reopening rape cases as Kentucky tests old DNA evidence

Kentucky has shipped 3,173 untested rape kits to a private laboratory in
Utah for forensic analysis, to determine if DNA evidence can be
retrieved.

April 15, 2017

Kentucky prosecutors must prepare for a wave of newly reopened sexual assault cases as several thousand previously untested sexual assault evidence kits — some dating back to the 1970s — begin to yield crucial DNA evidence, Attorney General Andy Beshear said this week.

So far, Kentucky has shipped 3,173 untested rape kits to a private laboratory in Utah for forensic analysis, to determine if DNA evidence can be retrieved. Of those kits, 1,469 have been tested, leading to 146 DNA profiles being entered into a national database maintained by the FBI. Those have produced 59 matches to samples already in the database, linking Kentucky assaults to other crimes or even to specific offenders.

No arrests have yet been made using newly retrieved DNA evidence, but police in Lexington and Louisville say they have started to reopen old investigations. This week, Beshear is hosting a three-day conference in Lexington to educate local prosecutors on how they can approach rape survivors and build criminal cases long after the initial investigations were closed.

"It was a national shame" when many states discovered piles of untested rape kits gathering dust in police custody, Beshear told the dozens of prosecutors who gathered on Monday. (In Kentucky, a 2015 state audit uncovered 3,090 untested rape kits. More recent estimates put the total closer to 3,800.)

"You all, in your jobs, know those aren't just boxes on a shelf," Beshear told the prosecutors.

"Each one represents the victim of a horrific crime who had the courage to report an under-reported crime," Beshear said. "And then they had the courage to undergo what each of you knows is one of the most invasive forensic exams that we can ever ask anyone to undergo. And what did we do in so many of those cases? We locked that courage — for whatever reason — in that box and we put it on a shelf."

Speaking at the conference, police detectives explained that it sometimes is difficult to locate survivors so many years after they reported an assault to tell them that DNA evidence has been recovered. People move or change names, or even die. Still, Kentucky now requires that rape survivors be informed whenever possible about the current status of the kits from their cases, the detectives said.

To avoid future backlogs, the Kentucky State Police central lab in Frankfort is roughly doubling its number of forensic-biology analysts to 30, said Whitney Collins, lab supervisor. The $4.5 million required to make that possible came from legal settlement funds provided by the attorney general's office.

Under Senate Bill 63, which the legislature passed last year, the state police lab must process rape kits for police departments more quickly, with an average turnaround time of 90 days required by next year and 60 days by 2020. The 2015 state audit found average wait times of eight months were not unusual for rape kit analysis.

In some major cities that are tackling rape kit backlogs, including Los Angeles, Detroit and Houston, analysts are finding matches to the national DNA database for more than 20 percent of the submitted kits, a University of Louisville researcher told the conference on Monday.

Getting a match, or a "hit," that links DNA from an old case to the national database is just the start of the process, police said. A "forensic hit" means the DNA matches samples submitted from one or more crime scenes elsewhere, which can be a useful clue, but it does not solve the case. An "offender hit" means the DNA can be linked to a specific offender whose DNA is on file, letting police zero in on a particular suspect.

As of this week, Lexington police say previously untested rape kits from their old cases have produced four matches with the national DNA database, although only one of those has provided detectives with new information they can use to pursue a criminal investigation.

More DNA matches are likely to follow soon, Fayette Commonwealth's Attorney Lou Anna Red Corn said in an interview.

"I was told by the lab that we can expect hits in about 35 percent of the cases," Red Corn said. "I think results are going to come in slow and steady. I anticipate that some of these cases are going to go forward. But as for what the exact number or percentage will be for us, I just don't know yet."

Beshear told the prosecutors that the cases soon to be reopened by old rape kits could be "the most important to ever cross your desks." Nearly half of Kentucky women "are subjected to some form of sexual violence in their lifetime," but only 3 percent of sexual assaults result in a criminal conviction, he said.

"These predators know that there is not a high likelihood right now that they are going to be thrown in jail," Beshear said. "I think all of us want to change that."

John Cheves: 859-231-3266, @BGPoliticsRead more here: http://www.kentucky.com/news/politics-government/article144205954.html#storylink=cpyRead more here: http://www.kentucky.com/news/politics-government/article144205954.html#storylink=cpy
...

Police begin reopening rape cases as Kentucky tests old DNA evidence | Lexington Herald Leader

Kentucky prosecutors must prepare for a wave of newly reopened sexual assault cases as several thousand previously untested rape kits — some dating back to the 1970s — begin to yield crucial DNA evidence, Attorney General Andy Beshear said this week.
Rate this blog entry:
CMPD’s Lost and Found: a ham and a tombstone
Ex-cop accused of evidence locker theft was back i...

Related Posts

Blotter - Latest News

News By Region

Keywords

side door prosecutors sloppy evidence control sheriff arrested stored as evidence stored evidence Property room rape kit stolen ammunition Texas Forensic Science Commission stolen guns prescription pills unwanted medications serial rapist storage bunker poor record keeping stolen marijuana rape kit audit Republican lawmakers show stolen drugs Thursday.Charles Holifield theft of money Property Control Room stealing drug evidence tapes edited stolen meth stolen cocaine Sexual assault Survivors Bill of Rights sentence to prison stealing drugs Wattier United Kingdom stealing guns prosecutor Property Clerk jobs sex crime settlement Year taking marijuana tampered evidence security camera footage work stolen jewelry Untested rape kit stolen money St steal drugs Sergeant Arrested rape kit standardarization strange evidence poop state prison property and evidence section Prosecutor Arrested sexual assault kit POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Washington State Patrol crime lab untestes rape kits theft of drugs rape evidence — report Wednesday Theft tampered drugs untested rape kits sentence to jail rape kit backlog Williams sexual assault task force police suicide Thursday property and evidence unit statute of limitations stolen cash state government Sheriff pleads guilty Suicide State trooper accused sheriff property room audit police storage Storage Property Room Jobs selling guns Transient property South Dakota Highway Patrolman Untested rape kits unit stealing money steal money Wrongful Conviction stolen cannabis police policy Property Rm Theft stolen methamphetamine police officer sentenced Sheriff Arrested rape kits stolen evidence stolen drug from evidence STOLEN CASH stolen gun Sexual assault kit property room inventory trial state chips untested sexual assault evidence policies Rape kit West Coast Rape Kits Backlog stolen OxyContin Trial at Riak Ventura County sheriff Via URL Browse Media Upload Wichita Police Department unsolved murder storage practices threw away evidence President Obama State/Province Signed Out Evidence Untested Sexual Kits police officer arrested PropertyRoom.com employee week state Division tampering with public record SAKs wrongful conviction skunky aroma wafted police Lt tape Tulare Police report Wrongful conviction State Agency Evidence Jobs urn withholding evidence sexual assault kits recovered property Vancouver BC Stolen pills trooper arrested property room sexual assault release of evidence Untest rape kits returned evidence Standards

Search IAPE